JUSTIN and Hailey Bieber have only fueled already growing rumors that their marriage is in trouble.
Fans have been deciphering clues and looking for any hidden meanings and messages in their recent appearances.
10
Hailey, 27, and Justin, 30, celebrated their fifth wedding anniversary in September, but there has long been speculation that their marriage is on the rocks.
However, the duo are reportedly desperate to stay together and are trying to work through their issues.
A source told The U.S. Sun, “Justin and Hailey are not separating but they have been going through a tough time.
“Divorce is not an option for them as it goes against their religious beliefs. They’re working on their marriage.”
READ MORE JUSTIN AND HAILEY
The insider went on, “Nobody’s moved out, but occasionally they are spending time apart by staying with family and friends, but they are really keen to stay together.”
Still, there are growing signs of a disconnect between the two.
PUT A RING ON IT
10
Earlier this week, fans noted that Hailey stepped out in public without her wedding ring on.
The model was said to be out for dinner with Kylie Jenner and Justine Skye at the Japanese restaurant Yazawa on Sunday, April 7.
While she did have a huge diamond ring visible on her left hand, fans argued the ring looked different from the band originally given to her by her husband of six years.
“Doesn’t she always wear her wedding ring?” one person asked on Reddit.
“Hailey hasn’t taken that ring off since she put it on. There is no way on God’s green earth she took it off now to replace it with another one,” someone else replied. “Something is going on for real.”
CRUSHING IT
10
Justin has been notably spending more time on social media, praising other women – including a former crush.
The Baby hitmaker – who previously admitted to having a “crush” on Rihanna – shared his appreciation when the star posed in some sexy lingerie to show off her new Savage X Fenty designs.
In the clip, Rihanna, 36, wore pale green underwear as she rolled around in bed.
Justin and Hailey’s Relationship Timeline
Photo credit: Patrick T. Fallon/AFP
Justin and Hailey go way back as she met him when she was just 12 years old during a 2009 Today show appearance.
In 2011, the two were pictured together along with Hailey’s father at Justin’s Never Say Never documentary premiere where she called him “cute.”
November 2014
- Dating rumors began after they were spotted together at a Hillsong Church service.
- During an interview with E! News, Hailey denied they were together.
- They also rung in 2015 together.
December 2015
- Dating rumors surfaced again after Hailey was spotted on vacation with Justin and his family in Tulum, Mexico.
- Later that month, they rang in the New Year again, but this time, they were spotted kissing at Leonardo DiCaprio’s New Year’s Eve party in St. Barts, according to People.
Feburary 2016
- Justin and Hailey acknowledged that they were in a relationship, but made it clear they were not exclusive.
- During another interview with E! News, Hailey said that the pair were “not an exclusive couple,” adding, “relationships at this age are already complicated, but I don’t really like to talk about it because it’s between me and him.”
- As for Justin, he spoke with GQ saying that Hailey was “someone I really love” but starting a serious relationship was not a good idea because there was already “a lot that [he had] to commit to,” including a tour.
- Later that year, the pair split in a “very dramatic excommunication,” according to People.
June 2018
- After Hailey and Justin called it quits, he got back together with Selena Gomez, but in May 2018, the pair called it quits for good.
- A few weeks later, Justin got back together with Hailey.
- “The common denominator, I promise you, is always church,” Hailey told Vogue, via People.
- “By then we were past the drama. I just gave him a hug. By the end of the conference, he was like, ‘We’re not going to be friends.’ I was like, ‘We’re not?’ “
- The pair went on to have a number of PDA-filled public appearances, confirming their relationship was back on.
July 2018
- Justin and Hailey announced their engagement.
- He popped the question during a romantic dinner in the Bahamas while they were on vacation, according to People.
- “Hailey I am soooo in love with everything about you! So committed to spending my life getting to know every single part of you loving you patiently and kindly,” Justin said in an Instagram post.
September 2018
November 2018
- Hailey changed her last name on social media from Hailey Rhode Baldwin to Hailey Rhode Baldwin Bieber.
September 2019
- Hailey and Justin had a wedding ceremony in front of their friends and family at the Montage Palmetto Bluff in Bluffton, South Carolina.
Fans noticed that Justin liked the video – only to later unlike it.
Justin had previously confessed to Chelsea Handler that he asked Rihanna on a date at the NBA All-Star game.
“Yeah, I asked her out. It didn’t go so well since I’m not with her,” he said on Chelsea Lately.
HALLOWEEN HAVOC
10
Justin has been open about his flirtations with other females in the past.
Last October, He was caught dancing around other women at a Halloween bash without his wife in attendance.
In a video exclusively obtained by The U.S. Sun, Justin was seen attending the annual Casamigos Halloween party.
Justin was surrounded by other women on the dance floor, all in costume, who danced close to him as colorful lights flashed around the venue.
SUPER SOLO
10
Hailey has also been seen partying without Justin.
The model rocked out with friend Khloe Kardashian in February, as Usher performed at the Super Bowl Halftime show in Las Vegas.
During the mini-concert, Hailey cuddled up to the Kardashians star and lip-synced the lyrics as Usher, 45, performed his hit song, Yeah!
Khloe grinned as she filmed her and Hailey pouting at the camera.
She then panned the camera over to model Winnie Harlow, who was dancing in the seat behind them.
There was no sign of Justin in the video.
CAR CRASH
10
When they do attend events together, fans are convinced they travel in separate cars.
One fan shared their concern on Reddit, asserting their opinion that the singer and model have been “living separately since last year.”
“All the concerts, restaurants and places they’ve been going to, they’ve been going separately and leave separately since last year,” the person posted. “This doesn’t seem like a break to me because it’s been a very long time.”
Justin and Hailey have been spotted separately leaving restaurants and bars in Los Angeles on multiple occasions in recent months, sparking concern among their fandom.
Cameras have caught the couple exiting venues into different vehicles and driving off by themselves.
WALK ON BY
10
The emotions don’t seem to be much better out of the car.
Earlier this year, they were spotted looking downcast while walking, with lots of space between them.
The A-list duo kept a low profile during a morning breakfast run in Beverly Hills.
Justin and Hailey were walking beside each other with nearly an arm’s span of space between them and appeared to be solemn and quiet.
The celebrities dressed casually with Justin wearing baggy cargo pants and a baseball cap.
Hailey also wore a baseball cap but instead wore sunglasses, jeans, and an oversized blazer.
PICTURE PERFECT
10
Fans think Hailey hinted at marital strife on her Instagram as they noticed she archived a slew of posts from her page.
One person pointed out the model’s significantly fewer posts on a popular online thread, noting that she was down to just 607 photos as of December 18.
“Gearing up for a divorce & a rebrand away from all things Bieber & her past,” they wrote over a screenshot of Hailey’s page.
Others agreed in the comments that the Victoria’s Secret model might be parting ways with her pop star husband.
LOVE HURTS
10
There was no love lost this Valentine’s Day when Hailey confessed she couldn’t remember the last time she had a happy holiday – despite being married to the pop star.
Hailey welcomed comedian Chelsea Handler to her YouTube show, Who’s In My Bathroom?
The two sipped champagne and indulged in fondue sweets, as they shared stories about the romantic holiday.
“What was your favorite Valentine’s memory ever?” Chelsea inquired. “Do you have one?”
The probing questions seemed to take Hailey by surprise, and she crumpled her face into a look of confusion before trying to answer.
“Ummmm….” she stalled, trying to come up with an answer, but only being able to say, “Been married for five years … can barely even think of it.”
Chelsea started laughing, half in humor, and half in sympathy.
“Oh no!” the former talk show host exclaimed. “She’s 27, and she’s been married for five years, and she’s already over Valentine’s Day.”